The Indictment that Matters Most
With the just-announced third indictment of Donald Trump, Jack Smith and the DOJ confront the tragic assault on American democracy
It’s happened. This third indictment of Donald J. Trump announced Tuesday is not just another indictment. This is the one that addresses his criminal efforts to hold onto power after losing a second term as president. This is the one that confronts his role in ending the two centuries-old history of peacefully transferring power from one president to the next, among the most sacred traditions of American democracy.
“Despite having lost,” the new indictment charges, “the Defendant was determined to remain in power.”
These words, no matter how surely we know their truth, have lost none of their power to stun when we reflect on the brazen desecration they represent. In a simple declarative sentence, they define a tragedy, its scale still being measured.
The indictment describes the flood of lies employed to overturn the results of the election: pushing state officials to ignore the real outcome, pressuring VP Mike Pence to change the results, organizing slates of “fake electors,” demanding that the Justice Department insist ]election fraud took place, exploiting the violent attack on the U.S. Capitol to stop Congress from certifying Joe Biden’s victory.
“These claims were false, and the Defendant knew that they were false,” the 45-page indictment asserts. “In fact, the Defendant was notified repeatedly that his claims were untrue—often by the people on whom he relied for candid advice on important matters, and who were best positioned to know the facts—and he deliberately disregarded the truth.”
The indictment, decided Tuesday by a grand jury in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., details four charges:
Conspiracy to defraud the U.S. government: The indictment alleges Trump conspired with six as-yet unnamed co-conspirators to “assist him in his criminal efforts to overturn the legitimate results of the 2020 presidential election and retain power.” (Details in the indictment suggest the co-conspirators include Rudy Giuliani, Sydney Powell, John Eastman, Jeffrey Clark and Kenneth Chesebro—lawyers all.)
Conspiracy to obstruct an official proceeding: This is focused on his efforts to obstruct Congress’ confirmation of Joe Biden’s win.
Obstruction of an official proceeding: This too is focused on Trump’s efforts to block Congress’ certification of the election on Jan. 6.
Conspiracy against rights: This charge specifically confronts Trump’s actions to block “the right to vote, and to have one’s vote counted.” This charge was first employed against the Ku Klux Klan after the Civil War, making it criminal to “injure, oppress, threaten or intimidate” people’s expression of their constitutional rights.
Special Counsel Jack Smith made clear in announcing the indictment what he thinks it all means. "The attack on our nation's Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, was an unprecedented assault on the seat of American democracy," he said. "As described in the indictment, it was fueled by lies. Lies by the defendant targeted at obstructing a bedrock function of the U.S. government.”
Predictably, Trump used this moment to insist it’s all just politics—"nothing more than the latest corrupt chapter in the continued pathetic attempt by the Biden Crime Family and their weaponized Department of Justice to interfere with the 2024 Presidential Election."
But political manipulations won’t stop the legal process now. Trump is scheduled to be arraigned in Washington, D.C. at 4 p.m. on Thursday.
In the coming days and weeks, we’ll have plenty more to discuss about the details of the indictment and what they portend for the defendant and the country.
But I offer here my conclusions from the early months after the Jan. 6 attack in a piece that depicted the significance of Trump shattering the sacred tradition of the peaceful transfer of power. Its title: “When a Jewel of Democracy is Lost.”
We all know how far his refusal to concede defeat has taken the country toward the destruction of democracy. That most Republicans doubt the outcome of the election and believe Trump is the “true president” demonstrates how powerful a lie of election fraud repeated over and over can be.
I’d like to say that the time will come when we can put this destructive behavior behind us. But much like the consequence of a child who grows up in an erratic, unstable home, real stability is lost; the wound can never be fully fixed. All that can be counted on is thoughtful people acting diligently to repair what’s broken and shine a light on the inspirational examples and positive values that can motivate the best among us to expand the majority committed to democracy and make a version of healing possible.
There will be rocky days ahead, but let’s not lose sight of the goal. May the latest indictment move the country a little bit further on the path toward repair.
America, America is sustained by paid subscriptions, making it possible to keep nearly all the writing available for everyone. If you’re not already a paid subscriber, I hope you’ll consider becoming one.
If he’s so innocent then he should welcome a trial before the election. The mass delusion of the GOP is a danger to our democracy. The rest of us must make sure our democracy still exists.
Reflecting on this moment, one is reminded of the famous lines by John Adams, one of the architects of American democracy, who stated, "We are a government of laws, not of men." Today, this phrase rings true with a renewed gravity as the third indictment of Donald J. Trump unfolds before us. This indictment isn't merely a statement of legal process; it is a fundamental assertion of American values and the enduring principle that no one is above the law.
At its heart, democracy is a covenant we make with each other, a sacred pact grounded in the mutual respect for the rule of law and the peaceful transition of power. The indictment represents a reckoning with a historical deviation from this pact. It unveils a tragedy whose scale is still under scrutiny, but what remains evident is the audacious attack on the core tenets of our democratic edifice.
The charges laid out in the indictment are not just legal technicalities. They embody the profound struggle between the facts and a deliberate dismissal of truth. This speaks to the importance of our collective commitment to discerning truth from falsehood and upholding our democratic values, even when faced with lies that are potent enough to sway public opinion.
We must never underestimate the power of untruths to erode the pillars of democracy, as clearly evidenced by the widespread belief among some that the election was fraudulent. To this end, we are reminded that the fight for democracy is continuous and demands the vigilance of us all.
While this indictment marks a significant step towards accountability, it should not be seen as a panacea. The wounds inflicted on our democracy are deep and their healing will require more than just legal action. Much like a traumatized child's journey to healing, it will require consistent nurturing, unyielding efforts to rectify the wrongs, and an unwavering commitment to uphold the truths we hold self-evident.
I echo the sentiment that the path forward will be arduous. Yet, I am hopeful. This indictment serves as a beacon, illuminating the path towards healing and reinforcing our collective commitment to democratic values. May it stir us all into action, inspire us to uphold the ideals of democracy, and guide us towards a more just and accountable political landscape.