77 Comments
Jan 28, 2023·edited Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

Part of the Culture of our Violence, are the things that "ENABLE" the violence.

Guns, without question, absolutely are Cause #1. Absolute evidence shows Strict Gun Law states and Countries have both Lower gun Homicides and Suicides.

So - how to change. This is obviously hard. But be not proud. Learn from the Anti-Abortion campaign:

A. Show vividly the actuals Deaths from guns. Gruesome sells in today's America

B. Hold gun owners and 2A absolutionists to Account - Make THEM feel Guilty. Make them OWN the deaths and bloodshed. It is all on them. On the NRA.

C. Attack the irrationality of the 2nd Amendement. - Defeat the idea that "this 2A"part of the Bill of Rights is "god-given" -- Many think Moses came down and gave 2A to Madison. Reject these arguements - loudly.

D. FOCUS -- We live in a clearly Partisan, Arbitrary Judical system. Personal preferences matter more that Judical history and decisions. The Conservative Supreme Court Justices entire philosophical foundation rests now on one principal ---- They are SMARTER than every other Justice before them. They have been given "divine" interpretation of the exact same words in the Constitution, but overturn dozens and hundreds of dumber prior Supreme Court Justices.

E. FOCUS on Gun Control at the ballot box. It will take 10 or 20 years.

F. Elect Democrats (ie not Sinema), who will when in power, pass the Judcial Act of 2026, 2028, 2030, that increases the Supreme Court size again - to have a majority of gun restricting Justices - again.

Expand full comment
author

This is an excellent, precise list. Thanks, Doug.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

Thank you Steve.

I'm an intrinsic problem solver. We only limit ourselves.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

Thank you. I want to feel safe in movie theaters and grocery stores again. I want our children and teacher friends to feel safe in schools. Your list is a very helpful guide. How does one ordinary citizen help effect these things? I vote -- always focusing on gun control, write letters to my representative and senators, both nationally and at the state level. Are there other steps I can take? Once I have ideas of more I can do, I will pass them on to others who have the same question.

Expand full comment

Most all Americans want to return to the world of sanity we once knew. I think you touched on the important action we can take over the next 2 to 10 years.

We need to prioritize Candidates for their clear position on gun control. We need to prioritize Senate candidates who openly will make Supreme Court decisions that overturn Heller and the insane "guns everywhere, at all times" postion of of the current crop of Conservative Justices.

Just like the Anti-Abortion crowd did for 30 years. That model worked. We can do the same

Expand full comment

More fundamentally, I believe we need an unstacked Supreme Court again. I’m hopeful there are palatable systemic reforms to achieve this, but don’t see any opportunity in the immediate future.

Expand full comment

It will be a while unfortunately. Hopefully the young Democrats grab a couple long term strategies and stick to them.

Expand full comment

Doug- Nice to hear a familiar (and decent) voice from The Dispatch! Great points.

Cheers

Expand full comment

Cheers Ed!! Nice to see you as well.

Expand full comment

Doug may I save and share this list with my friends and family? Thank you for it!

Expand full comment

Very much yes indeed Al.

Expand full comment

I immediately focused on ‘jacked up cops’... honestly, those guys were not only on a mission to claim a body, but they seemed high. They should have been subject to drug tests. It was inhuman. It was unconscionable. The fire department didn’t even render aid? I hope this investigation will be deep and thorough. My heart breaks for Tyre and his loved ones. And NONE of those officers should be out on bail. I put my faith in Chief Davis to get to the bottom of this. More women should be in positions of leadership. I will say this until the end of time. Thank you for the opportunity to respond, Steve.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for sharing your insights, Karen.

Expand full comment

The problem is the foot soldiers get blamed. It should be like the Navy. The captain goes down with the ship. Who is ultimately responsible for putting those cops in the position so they coukd get away with what they did? And without video they would've got away scot free. Until those people are held accountable nothing will change. It's like Abu Ghraib. Those soldiers never should've been there in the first place. Yet those ultimately responsible, Cheney and Bush, were never even mentioned. Our society is based on keeping the boss at arm's length. Middle management and workers get all the blame while the guys at the top skate.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

A major problem with law enforcement is they are recruited from the military. The role of the military is to have an Us. vs Them mentality. The military has a direct enemy who they are fighting. They are trained to have a 'warrior mentality'. It gives them a survival method. It is ingrained. Police should not have this mentality. But they do. They see civilians as the enemy against whom they must protect themselves and property. There is a specific training course that adheres to this. At this moment I don't recall the name of they guy who promotes it but it is used widely in the US. There is a reason the majority of people fear the police. They even look more like military than police. There also needs to be better psychological training to weed out people who are not suited to be cops. Qualified immunity needs to go. Have the lawsuits paid out of the police budget or pension and you will see a huge difference. Lastly, gun availability to the public is a major problem in this country. When you see someone all armed up just to go to Wal-mart, you have to ask yourself, what is that person afraid of? Most of these issues are the result of decades of step by step changes by select groups (ex NRA) towards their own goals. I fear it is going to take a horrendous event for any change to start.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

Your question this morning fills me with despair, mostly because even attempting such a sea change requires concerted energy and concentrated will power that we lack. When slaughter of innocent young children at school isn’t enough”; when an armed insurrection against our government isn’t enough; when the brutality of police who are sworn to protect and serve isn’t enough, I don’t know what ever will be. Where to even start? How about a remake and return to what police once were? Allies and trustworthy authority figures to whom we could turn for help and who were a part of the community, not sequestered in their own safe environment. They need to be demilitarized as well. Sadly it goes so much deeper with the demonization of those who “aren’t like us”. Different races, forgetting we all descend from the same gene pool out of Africa. LGBTQ+ because we believe they are sinners or whatever other lies we tell to justify marginalizing them. The poor, immigrants seeking a safer life. . .the list goes on. There is a major recalibration of the human story that needs to occur. How do we accomplish this? Regrettably I have only issues confronting us to catalogue. It takes the concerted and organized effort of each of us to create this massive cultural change.

Expand full comment
author

Apologies for the despair, Sara, but I always believe that the raising of the question and the dialogue that follows opens a door for movement...even change. As you aptly put it, this likely requires "a major recalibration of the human story."

Expand full comment

If we had a "true" history, not the one rewritten by the victors & revised by the church or kings/leaders that glosses over or whitewashes their geed & atrocities & demonizes their enemies like the "BuyBull".

How do we learn from mankind's mistakes?

Are we doomed to repeat them?

Is Aldous Huxley right? "That men do not learn very much from the lessons of history is the most important of all the lessons that history has to teach."

Expand full comment

Um police were formed out of slave patrols...

Expand full comment

That part. I’ve been lurking in the shadows of this conversation wanting to say what you said so simply. Until we address the gigantic white elephant in the middle of our discourse, we will never see an actionable consequence to the inevitable violence which occurs like clockwork. White supremacy concedes nothing. It is the driver (has always been) of the family van which is careening off a very slippery slope.

Expand full comment

It can start with movies and TV shows that are not violence ridden and glorify crime, murder and violence-good guys should always win and good values: honesty, self lessness and integrity promoted

Expand full comment

Where the cops are usually the “good guys” until one of them goes “bad.” In real life, the cops show up and all hell breaks loose.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023·edited Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

Thank you for your ongoing writing, ideas, and vision for American democracy! They are deeply appreciated! Responding to your question of today: Perhaps one thing almost all of us could do ~ as citizens, writers, journalists, neighbors ~ is to help "Redefine liberty to include freedom from violence." The idea comes from John Tirman, the late author, researcher, and man of conscience who wrote:

"Preventing gun violence will entail disrupting gun culture — redefining liberty to include freedom from violence, insisting that citizen safety is implicit in the Second Amendment, and scripting gun-free versions of Hollywood heroism. A tall order, but in April, one opinion poll asked, "Would you definitely vote for or definitely vote against a candidate for Congress who wants stricter gun control laws?" Sixty percent said “yes” to a stricter-law candidate. A cultural transformation? It just may be happening."

— John Tirman, author and longtime director of the MIT Center for Int'l Studies

Read his full 2018 commentary on reducing gun violence at:

https://shass.mit.edu/news/election-insights-2018-john-tirman-reducing-gun-violence

Expand full comment
author

Thanks for this. The idea of redefining freedom to include freedom from violence is very powerful.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023·edited Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

This has been a major preoccupation of mine ever since I had my own brush with a public gun violence incident about two weeks before Christmas.

Isn't REAL freedom the sense that you can go about your normal, daily life with relative safety and fairness in how you're treated?

Now, every time I leave the house there's that tiny flash of realization that I'm increasing the risk to my personal safety in going to the grocery store or to pick up some take out. Sure, the risk is still relatively small. Yet, it's still exponentially higher than if we lived almost anywhere else in the world.

We have more than one gun per capita here already. If more guns was going to solve anything, we'd already be there. Instead, I've come to realize that the ubiquitous access to guns in America enables any "good guy with a gun" to near instantaneously become a bad guy with a gun the moment they experience any emotional or psychological crisis. And a bad guy without a gun can go buy one on a whim with very little trouble.

My state did away with requiring permits for concealed carry in most public places, and I can assure you it's done nothing to make me feel safer. Especially in the wake of my own experience and continuing to see articles where someone was shot in the crossfire of a road rage incident at an intersection I used to pass 10 times a week on my way to and from work.

How do you have a functional society, or even a functional economy for that matter when we keep making it less and less enticing to actually leave our homes to do things?

That moment of existential dread before I go to the grocery store each week is slowly whittling away my interest in being a citizen of this country.

Expand full comment

That is exactly how I felt going to outdoor concerts last summer. Scanned high vantage points before I felt comfortable. Not safe, but at least comfortable. I am in Idaho and our illustrious legislators want to make open carry on college campuses allowed. Hell no!

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023·edited Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

We are a society without a safety net for those who fall through its cracks.

We are a society that treats health care and education as commodities rather than human rights.

We are a society that eschews common sense in favor of the American myth of individualism.

We are a society where the answers to our problems are glaringly obvious (the strict licensing of guns, for example).

But we are a society that is in thrall to unfettered capitalism and lacks the courage to enact real change.

Expand full comment

While our country’s as well as our world’s history bear out its’ inherent nature of man’s inhumanity to man, does not mean that we should at least try to continually lessen this carnage. New approaches must be tried. One could be introducing in all levels of schooling, courses that teach students alternative ways to resolve conflicts and learning about other religions and ethnicities highlighting the similarities not just the differences.

Let there be a counterbalance for students who only hear the negatives at home.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

Why haven't we enacted better laws to control guns and gun violence? Because not enough people voted for politicians who would write and pass those laws. Why are the police so brutal? Because our local leaders allow it, and we don't vote them out. The question is why the apathy on the part of the public? Have these things become so commonplace that we ignore them? I see examples of police violence in my town, but the City does nothing to stop it, and the public doesn't demand it. I don't demand it, even though it outrages me. Why?

Expand full comment

The public apathy astonishes me. I was asking why people weren't marching in the street when Obama's Supreme Court pick didn't even get a hearing (let alone approval) and I was met with yawns and a joke about how I'm a "radical."

I'm not. I just think we have to actually get our asses off our couch if voting doesn't work. I remember my friend going to school in the UK saying she couldn't understand why students were marching when tuition was hiked $200/year. It was so cheap! I told her that's WHY it was so cheap. Meanwhile, here we just passively accept private schools that cost $80k/year.

Expand full comment

I'm going to protest Pompeo when he speaks here in March. I'm thinking a picture of him dripping in blood. I haven't been to a protest in over 30 years.

Expand full comment

Excellent! I'm sure he'll be very annoyed.

Expand full comment

I'll say it again, the foot soldiers are not the problem. They do as they are trained.

Expand full comment

Thanks for a great article and ask. The free and unfettered access to guns of all sorts is insanity, and only action by the majority of the folks in this country to unleash its power to create the necessary rules - making assault rifles illegal without a strict vetting processes; creating nationwide regulations and licensing requirements, including mental health checks, of all owners/collectors of any firearms, along with measures they must follow for gun safety as a part of the rules - will this insanity stop. Common sense must prevail, which I believe it will, especially after recognition of the fiasco occurring in our House of Representatives finally is understood by not only the majority, but many of the MAGAs who will finally understand that these idiots are going to destroy the goose laying the golden eggs, thus their way of life. It was fun for them thinking they could destroy everything - but they are beginning to understand the consequences of such actions. Unfortunately, not all of them will, but we are still a nation supposedly led by the majority. My optimism says the majority will overcome this and be allowed to move on.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

Love the way you write. Your recent articles have been spot on and speaks to exactly where we’re at as a community and citizens. Thank you

Expand full comment
author

Thank you, Michelle.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023·edited Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

Thank you for a poignant piece.

Absolutely we can, Mr Beschloss. We have crises of despair and nihilism infecting our culture and our enemies foreign and domestic exploit this.

We need better education as a culture and more reverence for the spiritual, less for commercial interests. The almighty dollar has become too almighty. We need to place that reverence back on humanity, as our founders did. But our system is badly corrupted by immoral greed for money and power. The human condition - but one so much of modern humanity so hubristically ignores, religious dogma so obviously blown out by rational observation.

The teachings of Joseph Campbell offer a way forward, an answer to Nietzche’s famous rationalization that “God is Dead.” That God inside all of us is certainly not, we just need some new, convincing and fitting mythologies to bring that morality and spirituality to a more fundamental place in our society. American Evangelical Christianity is failing us especially.

Otherwise the Hitlers Putins and Trumps of the world will eventually rule over over us.

https://radmod.substack.com/p/thus-answered-joseph-campbell

Expand full comment
author

Thank you, Ed.

Expand full comment

Tom Nichols wrote about this recently in the Atlantic - I think he hits the mark. The problem is more fundamental than gun control law and not particularly new either, though it does seem to get worse and worse.

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/01/lost-boys-violent-narcissism-angry-young-men/672886/

Expand full comment

Who is raising all these angry young men?

Expand full comment

Hard to put a real finger on it, but I'll give you my $0.02 since you asked!

The internet and screens, too much of the time. Actual mothers and fathers, extended family and friends not enough of the time. Doesn't help the newest tech titans have become obscenely wealthy and popular by pushing "engagement" aka unhealthy, self-reinforcing psychological habits, aka addiction. With post-truth politics and associated cynicism so obviously infecting much of our leadership, despair and nihilism are all-too-easy to embrace, parents and kids alike. Entertainment has become really good and easy to bury oneself in.

I feel lucky I escaped my youth mostly before the internet and cell phones were ubiquitous. But so much of the problem is structural too, capitalism run amok, so busy rat-racing, we've created stressful, inhumane structures where too many kids fall thru the cracks.

It takes a village and when the whole village fails, the ugly places of the internet offer kids a place to fit in where they are just an anonymous voice among millions, and there they are subject to radicalization.

Expand full comment

Wow, I have not seen the name Joseph Campbell come up in years.

Thanks for bringing him to the attention of readers here.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

Steve, thanks for this. I hate to use cliches, but where there’s a will, there’s a way. We can definitely end the violence culture if we really wanted to and we’re willing to give it our all and persist. The national will needs to be strengthened.

Expand full comment
author

It's always a matter of will--and motivating people to pay attention and act. Thanks, John.

Expand full comment

Perhaps that’s why people like DeSantis don’t want children to be taught about slavery and the annihilation of Native American tribes. If children are properly educated, in the truth, they might change their ways.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023Liked by Steven Beschloss

The violence we are experience is a byproduct of our current “politics of division”. As long as these events happen to “others” there will be no change. Communities traditionally self-police for belonging to a community means there is a barrier to entry and rules (created by the community) that must be followed remain in the community. Until a critical mass is reached and the community says no there will not be meaningful change. Sigh

Let’s hope we reach the tipping point soon.

Expand full comment

Republicans seem to thrive on violence. It’s disappointing and disgusting that our justice system hasn’t dealt with everyone including the ring leaders and Trump regarding the events of January 6.

Expand full comment

If fear not without some catalyzing event, which given all the has happened in the last 10 years, is too disturbing to envision what that might be.

Expand full comment

Al, you are correct. The question is what will the catalyzing event be?

In Germany and Japan it took a total national defeat and occupation. Here, in the US, we have one attempt that succeeded and two attempts that have failed, at this type of change. Outlawing slavery has 99.9% succeeded. Prohibition failed and Civil Rights laws have failed.

Any astute visitor to Germany can see that while violence has pretty much been dispelled the racial superiority still exists in many quarters. This is true in Japan as well. National aggression is, most likely gone, for several reasons, but racial superiority still exists in many quarters.

The question remains. What will the catalyzing event be?

I wish I had the answer.

Expand full comment

An Alien invasion from outer space. Seriously, things are that bad.

Expand full comment

I fear the answer.

Expand full comment

First we need to clean up our government so our elected officials truly represent the will of the people, not of corporations. Also stop giving Cops paid leaves for killing people.

Expand full comment

And then we need to deal with the corrupt Supremes!

Expand full comment

As a female I have never felt safe, in public and at home. Toxic, violent, male behavior is what needs to be changed first to stop this pandemic of violence. Men need to re-train men. The rest of us are just on the receiving end in a game of Russian Roulette.

Expand full comment

Yes, I agree. Any analysis that does not look at the common denominator - males - is incomplete. As to guns, it is men's fetish with guns that is at the root of why we haven't been able to change this insane epidemic.

Expand full comment

End #CitizensUnited & therefore, the GOP stranglehold on Dem Voters Voices!

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2023·edited Jan 28, 2023

I am not holding out any hope. People actually put the gun humpers in charge of our House just two months ago. Whatever it was that was passed last year was largely symbolic. One other observation, if these were white cops I doubt they'd a been charged so quickly. And we all know iit.

Expand full comment

It's the damn guns, first and foremost. Then it is the mentality of many in law enforcement. Here in Boise, Idaho we have a scandal of an officer who pretended to be offended by the former chief who later resigned. Then it came out that he was slated to speak at a white nationalist conference. Needless to say, the chief was Asian from Portland. I knew when he was interviewed by a local NBC affiliate that he was lying then, my instinct was spot on about him.

So, it is not only guns but the mentality of many people that own guns (not all of course). Longer and better background checks first and foremost. Age 21 and older, no compromise. I feel firearms should be licensed and have insurance policies. We have that just to drive a vehicle, why not guns and rifles?

Expand full comment

Are people good or bad? This ? is as old as time. The answer is both. John Gotti who could murder people and then, go eat dinner, was loved by hundreds in his Queens neighborhood for the parties he threw for them and for "taking care" of anyone who robbed or looted them. Judas followed and worked miracles with Jesus for three years before betraying him for 30 pieces of silver. A policeman can have a mother, wife, children, go to church, cross himself and sponsor orphans, yet go to work and kick,cripple, kill, then plead not guilty.

I don't know how many people read/comment on this column, but we can pontificate, sermonize, propose all the answers possible to fix the problems, but they remain. Yes, we should ban guns, train police, gripe about those in power, but to what end? As Cher would say, the beat goes on. The only protesting I can think of that ever brought anything to fruition were the ones for civil rights led by MLK.

George Floyd-2020 protests. Tyre Nichols-2023 protests. The next one is right around the corner, and it just keeps finding new corners.

The only answers I can think of are voting and education. It should be intelligent, sane, compassionate leaders standing on the soap boxes. Vote for them......in numbers;don't miss one chance. And if, like Ron DeSantis, those in power interfere with teaching the truth, vote them out and hire teachers who are readers, forever students, motivators, upright, who even tho paid paltry sums, give their working lives to make better, more informed citizens to be.

(True about puppies. I know of a woman who wished for the company of a mistreated, rescued dog. , She was all of 70 years old and they said no, too old ! )

Expand full comment

Yes, the beat goes on to the next corner..as disenfranchised votes/voices are being undermined by legislation across the country..The candidates who say they won’t take PAC or Corp money, I tell them to find your moral compass from your Senate or House seat..They first must get elected..We are in desperate times, I am not seeing the desperate measures needed to right this ship..All one need do is see who is being put into positions of more power in Congress, book banning, the corrupt SCOTUS to see the Fascism sweeping our Democracy..For years if been putting forward we are in desperate times, but where are the desperate measures?

Expand full comment

Any analysis that does not look at the common denominator - males - is incomplete. It stares us in the face yet reporters and those interviewed about violence and mass shootings just ignore this fact!

As to guns, it is men's fetish with guns/toxic masculinity that is at the root of why we haven't been able to change this insane epidemic.

Expand full comment

Domestic violence is a factor in 2/3rds of mass shootings (either a direct connection or a history) yet there is barely any reporting on this subject. It infuriates me.

Expand full comment

And a thousand women a year are killed by their partners. Don't hear much about that either!

Expand full comment

Only when those who’s default behavior is violence are taught, then begin to recognize and see a violent path does not lead to solutions to our differences..The lessons used to do the teaching will be the key..They may very well have to be in the form of Desperate Measures..After all, we are in Desperate Times..

Expand full comment

The well heeled gun lobby roams the halls of Congress, the Congressional leaders unwilling to enact gun registration laws, their fear of losing campaigns should they outlaw automatic weapons, a segment of society that holds dear the antiquated well armed militia” amendment and an uneducated belief system that condones violence and retaliation handed down by generations. I don’t have the answers to society’s ills. I do know that our nation is in trouble.

Expand full comment

Some of the problems lie obviously with the SCOTUS and their ludicrous 2nd amendment interpretation. And since our present SCOTUS is corrupt, above the law, and in place for years to come, the only way to fix this is to increase the number of justices, giving Biden the opportunity to nominate six more justices which would all be confirmed by our present democratic Senate. This is doable. It just takes political will on the part of the president. If he does this by EO, it *might* destroy his campaign for 2024, but having 15 justices in place would greatly outweigh the benefits of having him serve a second term. And what a legacy it would be! Is there anyone who could make this argument to him successfully?

Expand full comment

No, we cannot change our culture of violence because it is not innate to American culture it is innate to human nature and thus to virtually all cultures to one degree or another. Humanity hasn't evolved as much as we'd like to think over the last 3000, 4000 years. We're still largely primitive creatures that want to destroy the person in the other tribe.

Expand full comment

But why are Americans *more* primitive than citizens of other nations?

Expand full comment

I don't think ALL Americans are more primitive than citizens of other countries. Rather, some of the cultures/peoples who settled America over the last few centuries are more primitive. In this piece I wrote here I draw on Colin Woodson's work on how there are about 10 different cultures warring over political and ideological control over America. Some are much more primitive and destructive than others, particularly the Greater Appalachia and Deep South cultures, in my humble opinion: https://godofthedesert.substack.com/p/why-i-have-no-animosity-toward-michigan?utm_source=profile&utm_medium=reader2

Also, when we look at cultures in a global context we can see much greater primitivism than much of America. In my view a great barometer for determining just how primitive a culture and/or nation is is the level of antisemitism it possesses. In the 2nd installment in my antisemitism and culture series I lay out how wide the disparity is here around the world: https://godofthedesert.substack.com/p/what-causes-someone-to-be-an-antisemite In the US, roughly 9% of the people are antisemitic (that's probably gone up more in recent years, though.) In other countries around the world the rate of antisemitism is over 30%, over 50%, or even as high as over 70% or 80% in many Middle Eastern countries. Even a European country like Greece has a 69% rate of antisemitism.

Given the imperial, genocidal war which Russia is now raging against Ukraine it's also worth asking: which country is actually more primitive, us in America or Russia? Russia has much less of a culture of freedom than we do, its people much more content with authoritarian rulers like Vladimir Putin and significant numbers so depressed they're drinking themselves to death on cheap vodka in absurdly large numbers.

Expand full comment

Obviously, I didn’t mean *all* Americans. But I *am* reminded of D.H. Lawrence, who said that "the essential American soul is hard, isolate, stoic, and a killer.” I’m sure he didn’t have *all* Americans in mind either, and he died in 1930, so he’s not referring to our present population. But it seems rather prescient.

Expand full comment

I would agree with that sentiment. Are you familiar with George Carlin's immortal words on a similar theme? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fgAVpPNusTs

"We like war! We're a war-like people! We like war because we're good at it! You know why we're good at it? Cause we get a lot of practice. This country's only 200 years old and already, we've had 10 major wars. We average a major war every 20 years in this country so we're good at it! And it's a good thing we are; we're not very good at anything else anymore! Huh? Can't build a decent car, can't make a TV set or a VCR worth a fuck, got no steel industry left, can't educate our young people, can't get health care to our old people, but we can bomb the shit out of your country all right! Huh? Especially if your country is full of brown people; oh we like that don't we? That's our hobby! That's our new job in the world: bombing brown people."

There probably is a greater degree of toughness and individualism in the American character, mostly related to our status as an immigrant nation and longtime frontier culture, but I don't know I'd necessarily characterize that as primitivism so much as a response to the nature of the world and humanity in general.

I apologize, I have grown somewhat cynical about human nature in general. And made another Carllin sentiment one of my mantras over the last year and a half as I've been trying to recover from PTSD caused by being a victim of police brutality in September 2021: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rVXekzwkz10

“Now, there's one thing you might have noticed I don't complain about: politicians. Everybody complains about politicians. Everybody says they suck. Well, where do people think these politicians come from? They don't fall out of the sky. They don't pass through a membrane from another reality. They come from American parents and American families, American homes, American schools, American churches, American businesses and American universities, and they are elected by American citizens. This is the best we can do folks. This is what we have to offer. It's what our system produces: Garbage in, garbage out. If you have selfish, ignorant citizens, you're going to get selfish, ignorant leaders. Term limits ain't going to do any good; you're just going to end up with a brand new bunch of selfish, ignorant Americans. So, maybe, maybe, maybe, it's not the politicians who suck. Maybe something else sucks around here... like, the public. Yeah, the public sucks. There's a nice campaign slogan for somebody: 'The Public Sucks. F*ck Hope.”

Expand full comment

Yup. That’s pretty much it. Both on wars and politicians.

Expand full comment
founding

Good question as always Steve: let's start with what we can accuately accomplish as voters--in other words "politics" rather than "culture" which is far more elusive: 1) Inasmuch as the fanatics are currently in charge of the House, I suggest that they will burn their own House down in the next 21 months and it will greatly benefit Democrats' opportunity of wining a very strong majority of twenty seats or more (CA and NY alone could flip 10 seats)! While of course we will have difficulty in the Senate, the only two seats in real trouble are Montana (Tesla) and of course WVA. But, inasmuch as the crazies are in the Senate too, there may be an opportunity to gain one or two seats as well as win Montana as Tesla is a strong retail campaigner. Therefore, adopt Doug's very precise approach in the next Congress:

"F. Elect Democrats (ie not Sinema), who will when in power, pass the Judcial Act of 2026, 2028, 2030, that increases the Supreme Court size again - to have a majority of gun restricting Justices - again."

Expand full comment

I think we need to work on both tracks for best chances of success - we’ll have escalating political crises until we address the underlying cultural poison, as far as I can tell.

Expand full comment

How exactly do we do that? Most southern states are still fighting the end of slavery for crying out loud.

Expand full comment

It's interesting to me that we as a society freely share videos of people being beaten to death by police, but we never share videos of gun violence.

From what I've heard, the kids at Sandy Hook literally had their heads blown off. I don't know if gun violence needs to be shown, since nothing is happening in terms of police reform, but we may need a parent to share an image like this, much like Emmett Till's mother did.

In terms of police reform, we need police to pay lawsuits out of their own pensions. These beatings and shootings will stop right quick.

In terms of gun reform, we need licensing, training, insurance, fines if your gun is stolen and not reported and is then used in a crime, and jail for parents whose kids use their guns. Also, ammo should cost a LOT.

Expand full comment

Nuff said! I do agree.

Expand full comment